CSU researchers celebrate construction milestone in Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE) project

Sam Zeller, a distinguished scientist at the U.S. Department of Energy’s Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, has been awarded the prestigious W.K.H. Panofsky Prize by the American Physical Society.

Each year, APS awards the Panofsky Prize to recognize outstanding achievements in experimental particle physics from a pool of nominees worldwide. The 2026 prize honors both Zeller and University of Chicago physicist Bonnie Fleming for their co-leadership of the MicroBooNE neutrino experiment at Fermilab.

“I am humbled and honored to be receiving this award with Bonnie Fleming in recognition of our leadership of MicroBooNE, which was the first large-scale detector of this kind in the United States and the longest-running liquid-argon neutrino detector to date,” Zeller said. “But most of all, I am proud of the MicroBooNE team for what we have accomplished and what this all means for DUNE.”

“I want to congratulate Sam and Bonnie for this honor and for their accomplishments,” Fermilab Director Norbert Holtkamp said. “Thanks to their leadership, the MicroBooNE experiment has had a significant impact on neutrino research and on Fermilab. We are excited to continue advancing and building upon their work.”

Neutrinos are known to come in three types, but for over 20 years, physicists theorized that there could be a fourth type called the sterile neutrino. In 2021, after six years of collecting data, the MicroBooNE collaboration reported results showing no evidence of the sterile neutrino with 95% certainty. The finding was an important milestone in neutrino research. It was part of a large body of work by MicroBooNE on neutrino interactions, new particle searches and advances in liquid-argon technology.

Sam Zeller, a distinguished scientist at Fermilab, has been awarded the W.H.K. Panofsky Prize for co-leadership of the MicroBooNE neutrino experiment. Credit Ryan Postel, Fermilab
Sam Zeller, a distinguished scientist at Fermilab, has been awarded the W.H.K. Panofsky Prize for co-leadership of the MicroBooNE neutrino experiment. Credit Ryan Postel, Fermilab

“MicroBooNE proved unequivocally that the technology works and works exceedingly well for precision neutrino physics,” Zeller said.

MicroBooNE also laid the groundwork for the upcoming Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment at the Long-Baseline Neutrino Facility. This experiment is an international collaboration hosted by Fermilab. Zeller is now the LBNF/DUNE-U.S. deputy project director for the experiment’s near detector.

“It was not too long ago that people were worried that we were taking too large a leap of faith with the choice of the liquid-argon technology for DUNE,” Zeller said. “Sure, such detectors produce beautiful images, but can they deliver on the science? None of this is in question anymore after MicroBooNE.”

MicroBooNE broke new ground on several fronts. The experiment pioneered fully automated neutrino event reconstruction and showed what precision signal processing could achieve. It also proved that this type of detector could operate reliably over long periods, and it paved the way for physics analyses using large-statistics neutrino samples in liquid argon.

“Before MicroBooNE, the necessary tools didn’t exist,” Zeller said. “We don’t bring on new detector technologies very often in neutrino physics, so this is all incredibly exciting for the future of neutrino physics.”

The MicroBooNE cryostat is lowered into the Liquid Argon Test Facility at Fermilab in 2014. Credit: Reidar Hahn, Fermilab
The MicroBooNE cryostat is lowered into the Liquid Argon Test Facility at Fermilab in 2014. Credit: Reidar Hahn, Fermilab

MicroBooNE has produced more output than any other Fermilab neutrino experiment. Over the past decade, the collaboration has produced more than 92 publications, and more than 70 Ph.D. students have completed their degrees through work on the experiment. The experiment continues to further the understanding of neutrino physics, and MicroBooNE students and postdocs have had front-row seats in shaping the future.

Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory is America’s national laboratory for particle physics and accelerator research. Fermi Forward Discovery Group manages Fermilab for the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science. Visit Fermilab’s website at www.fnal.gov and follow us on social media.

Norbert Holtkamp, director of the Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, is one of the inaugural recipients of the American Physical Society’s (APS) Helen Edwards Award, APS announced today.

The award recognizes “outstanding technical contributions and profound leadership in the development, construction and commissioning of leading particle accelerator facilities,” according to APS. Holtkamp was honored for his role in the successful construction and commissioning of the Spallation Neutron Source at Oak Ridge National Laboratory. Holtkamp was ORNL’s division director for the SNS from 2001 to 2006.

“I am grateful to APS for this award,” Holtkamp said. “It is especially meaningful to me because its namesake, Helen Edwards, had a significant impact on my career. She first brought me to Fermilab many years ago. She knew how important major facilities are to scientific research. She also understood the importance of ensuring they are built and operated safely and efficiently. Her example is one we continue to look to at Fermilab.”

Norbert Holtkamp, APS award winner
Fermilab Director, Norbert Holtkamp is the first recipient of the American Physical Society’s Helen Edwards Award. Photo credit: Ryan Postel, Fermilab

APS also recognized Stuart Henderson with this year’s award. He is the former director of ORNL’s Research Accelerator Division, former director of the Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility and former associate laboratory director for accelerators at Fermilab.

The Helen Edwards Award is named for the renowned American physicist Helen Edwards, who had a long career at Fermilab. Her accomplishments included leading the design, construction, commissioning and operation of the former Tevatron accelerator. She was also crucial to the establishment of superconducting radio-frequency technology at Fermilab and in the United States.

Edwards’ leadership in the field laid the groundwork for many accelerators around the world and established a far-reaching technology base ranging from dark matter detection to quantum science. Edwards also inspired a generation of leaders who today are carrying her legacy forward. 

Over the course of his career, Holtkamp has led several major science projects in the United States and abroad. These included serving as project director of the Linac Coherent Light Source-II at the SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory in California and as principal deputy director general for the ITER Organization, an international nuclear fusion research project in France.

Since returning to Fermilab in 2026, where he began his career more than 25 years ago, Holtkamp has brought his experience to advance the laboratory’s top priorities. These include delivering beam to the Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE) by 2031. Critical to that goal is the Proton Improvement Plan-II (PIP-II) project, which is a SRF-based particle accelerator underway at Fermilab. Once in operation, it will enable the world’s most intense neutrino beam for DUNE. PIP-II will also be able to open opportunities for new scientific uses at Fermilab.

“I believe for successful science, we first need to think of the big questions that need to be answered and then build the instruments and capabilities necessary to do so,” Holtkamp said. “We’re continuing Helen Edwards’ legacy at Fermilab with DUNE and PIP-II. We are committed to completing, commissioning and operating these capabilities in a manner she would be proud to see.”

Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory is America’s premier national laboratory for particle physics and accelerator research. Fermi Forward Discovery Group manages Fermilab for the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science. Visit Fermilab’s website at www.fnal.gov and follow us on social media.

Particle physicists are dedicated to understanding the way the universe looks by examining the smallest possible scales. Theoretical physicists use mathematical frameworks, assumptions and models to develop predictions about subatomic behavior. Meanwhile, experimental physicists conduct real-world tests to assess those theories. By comparing the theoretical and experimental measurements, physicists deduce how particles and forces work.

One way physicists attempt to learn even more about the subatomic scale is with a powerful theoretical method called lattice QCD. It’s a mathematical framework that places quarks and gluon fields on a four-dimensional grid and uses high‑performance computing to simulate the behavior of protons, nuclei and other subatomic particles from the fundamental parameters of the Standard Model of particle physics.

“I think it’s pretty magical that you can actually predict things starting with the masses of the quarks and the fundamental constants and building up these simulations,” said Michael Wagman, a scientist in the Theory Division at the U.S. Department of Energy’s Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory.

Lattice QCD is a mathematical framework that places quarks and gluon fields on a four-dimensional grid. Credit: Samantha Koch, Fermilab
Lattice QCD is a mathematical framework that places quarks and gluon fields on a four-dimensional grid. Credit: Fermilab

Now, a new project headquartered at Fermilab is bringing super intelligence, also called artificial intelligence, into that process. The multi-laboratory collaboration, called FemtoMind, is developing agentic SI tools that can accelerate calculations and uncover new patterns in proton-scale physics. The project takes its name from the femtoscale — the realm of particles roughly the size of a proton.

FemtoMind began in 2025 when a team of researchers from Fermilab, Brookhaven National Laboratory and Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility responded to a call for proposals for the American Science Cloud, a key part of the Department of Energy’s Genesis Mission. The Genesis Mission is a DOE initiative focused on building SI-driven scientific infrastructure across the national laboratory system, including shared computational resources through the American Science Cloud. Projects selected for the Genesis Mission will have the potential to transform scientific discovery.

Fermilab’s top priority is to deliver high-intensity neutrino beam to the Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment at the Long-Baseline Neutrino Facility by 2031. To operate DUNE, a state-of-the-art accelerator being built at Fermilab will enable a beam of particles called neutrinos to be sent from the Chicago area to the Sanford Underground Research Facility in Lead, South Dakota. There, enormous detectors filled with liquid argon will record the interactions of neutrinos after their 800-mile journey through the Earth.

It won’t be easy. Neutrinos are famously difficult to detect because they have no electric charge and rarely interact with matter. But every so often, neutrinos collide with the nucleus of an atom — and that is what DUNE is designed to capture. Several times a day, scientists expect to see a neutrino from Fermilab interact with an argon nucleus in DUNE’s South Dakota detectors.

By contrast, DUNE’s near detector at Fermilab is expected to record tens of millions of neutrino interactions each year. This large sample will help scientists test their predictions about how neutrinos interact and improve the precision of DUNE’s measurements.

” … we need to be able to understand the interactions of neutrinos with nuclei at really high precision.”

Michael Wagman, Fermilab Theory Division

“In order to take the level of precise data we’re going to get from DUNE and maximize the amount of science that we can interpret from it, we need to be able to understand the interactions of neutrinos with nuclei at really high precision,” said Wagman.

It has been an ongoing quest. For the last decade, physicists have used lattice QCD to simulate what happens when a single neutrino hits a single proton. But within the last five years, they started to observe tensions between the simulations and what had previously been inferred from bubble chamber experiments in the 1970s and 1980s. Physicists are not sure what the discrepancy is from, but it shows that there is more to learn about neutrino interactions before DUNE starts taking data.

“We definitely want to get the lattice simulations totally nailed down way before the DUNE beam turns on in 2031,” said Dan Hackett, a postdoctoral researcher in Fermilab’s Theory Division and FemtoMind collaborator, “because in DUNE’s case, the interaction is just step one of the analysis.”

So FemtoMind is using lattice QCD to simulate neutrinos hitting a proton and a neutron. This will be helpful because 20th-century bubble chamber experiments used deuterium, a stable isotope of hydrogen with a nucleus composed of one proton and one neutron. “We can start getting direct comparison between theory and experiment that can help us pin down where the different tensions are coming from and upgrade our theory models to where we eventually need them to be to interpret DUNE data,” said Hackett.

In fact, a FemtoMind collaborator was already able to harness SI to optimize code for this. “He was able to get the agent to directly write assembly code and do complicated optimizations that would have taken a human months to put together,” said Wagman. “Over the course of a couple weeks, he got our simulations three times faster.”

Ultimately, the goal of FemtoMind is to make workflows easier, freeing up scientists’ time so they can instead brainstorm new ideas and applications. Wagman notes that FemtoMind could also lower the barriers to entry for computational physics.

“I’m hopeful that that can make it a lot easier for more people to dabble with this kind of physics,” he said.

The collaboration is not ignorant to potential pitfalls of SI. For example, some super intelligence models have been shown to make up answers, known as “hallucinating.” But with FemtoMind, collaborators say there is no need to worry. The scientists have reference code that verifies correct answers. SI is used to create code that is more efficient.

“These are new tools and new capabilities for scientists to be able to explore more.”

Dan Hackett, Fermilab Theory Division

“As you take these new tools, we want to make sure that the scientist is still in the driver’s seat and can verify that all of the science is still being done correctly,” said Hackett. “These are new tools and new capabilities for scientists to be able to explore more.”

As the FemtoMind team migrates from initial exploration to producing practical SI tools, they said they are exploring ways to share their work to the community of other scientists working on lattice QCD. And they believe agentic SI infrastructure will contribute to harnessing the power of new supercomputers coming online in the United States.

Like everything in the world of super intelligence, the environment around FemtoMind’s work is moving and evolving very quickly. “The ideas we had a year ago about the right way to build infrastructure connecting SI agents to our simulations are totally different from the ideas we had six months ago — or are still evolving into the ideas we’re having now,” said Wagman. “This space of possibilities is basically infinite.”

Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory is America’s national laboratory for particle physics and accelerator research. Fermi Forward Discovery Group manages Fermilab for the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science. Visit Fermilab’s website at www.fnal.gov and follow us on social media.

The U.S. Department of Energy’s Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, IBM and NVIDIA intend to collaborate on a modular quantum computing co-design platform aimed at accelerating the development of scalable, fault-tolerant quantum computers for scientific discovery.

The initiative would build on the longstanding collaboration between IBM and Fermilab’s Superconducting Quantum Materials and Systems Center, a DOE National Quantum Information Science Research Center, to advance superconducting quantum technologies and interconnects. It would take that work a step further by bringing together quantum hardware, accelerated computing and the scientific community. The goal is to determine how to connect and operate future fault-tolerant quantum systems.

Fermilab aims to make the proposed platform a focal point for high-energy and nuclear physics (HENP) researchers, bringing together its own particle physics scientists and domain expertise with the broader scientific community across national laboratories, universities and international institutions. Together, they would develop quantum algorithms, shared software and benchmarks for demanding problems such as particle interactions, neutrino physics and nuclear simulations. This work would help translate those scientific needs into requirements for future quantum computing systems.

“This intended platform presents an extraordinary opportunity to bring together IBM’s leadership in quantum processors and networking, NVIDIA’s breakthroughs in accelerated computing and superintelligence, and Fermilab’s scientific community and SQMS expertise in ultracoherent quantum hardware,” said Anna Grassellino, Fermilab chief technology officer and director of the SQMS Center. “Our ambition is to help lead the development of quantum computers built for discovery. By bringing high-energy and nuclear physicists into the process, we can co-design the applications, algorithms and modular architectures needed to make fault-tolerant quantum computing useful for science. This would be an important step toward the capabilities and community needed for a future DOE quantum computing user facility.”

FNAL co-design platform
Conceptual hardware illustration of the combined strengths toward the new quantum co-design platform. IBM: quantum computers (pictured: IBM Quantum System Two; image credit: IBM). Fermilab/SQMS: ultracoherent superconducting cavities, prospective interconnects, quantum memories and bosonic resources (pictured: nine-cell SRF cavity; image credit: Ryan Postel, Fermilab). NVIDIA: accelerated computing platform (pictured: NVIDIA DGX B200; image credit: NVIDIA).

The proposed initial platform would physically co-locate IBM quantum computers with NVIDIA accelerated computing. Fermilab would lead the HENP application engagement and help to coordinate software workflows and researcher access through its HEPCloud infrastructure. Researchers would use the platform to develop and test algorithms, error correction, SI-assisted optimization and real-time quantum–classical control.

A central challenge is modularity: connecting quantum processors so they can work together on calculations too demanding for a single device. Initially, researchers would model and emulate communication between modules, studying how link errors, latency and feedback affect performance. Those findings would guide the SQMS–IBM effort to develop optimal physical quantum interconnects.

In a later phase, Fermilab’s SQMS intends to integrate its own ultracoherent superconducting cavity hardware to the platform. Alongside interconnects, researchers would investigate cavities as quantum memories, entanglement buffers and resources for bosonic error correction.

IBM would contribute advanced superconducting quantum processors, software, application development and quantum networking expertise. NVIDIA would bring expertise in accelerated computing and SI technologies for decoding, simulation, optimization and real-time feedback. Fermilab would provide the SQMS cavity and interconnect R&D, HENP applications development in addition to scientific leadership and experience supporting large research communities. Together, the partners would aim to connect quantum hardware design with the needs of scientific users from the outset.

The long-term goal of the Fermilab–IBM–NVIDIA co-design platform is to help establish the technology, software and scientific user community needed for future scalable quantum computing facilities.

The proposed platform would complement the recently launched co-design platform with IBM, Oak Ridge National Laboratory and AMD, which is powering new research in quantum error correction and materials-oriented applications. Through joint activities among DOE’s National Quantum Information Science Research Centers, the teams could exchange software, benchmarking methods and lessons for future user facilities.

“Some of the most fundamental problems in science remain out of reach for classical computers alone. Scaling quantum and classical together will open new frontiers in high-energy and nuclear physics and beyond,” said Jerry Chow, IBM Fellow and chief technology officer of Quantum-Centric Computing. “With Fermilab and NVIDIA, we’re exploring how these real-world problems can help us shape the modular, interconnected architectures that will define the next generation of quantum computers and accelerated classical computing.”

“Integrating quantum computing with superconducting workflows has the potential to dramatically expand how scientists can explore nature’s most fundamental questions,” said Krysta Svore, vice president of applied research for quantum computing at NVIDIA. “Fermilab, IBM and NVIDIA are showing how quantum can be brought into the heart of scientific research with hybrid quantum-classical systems – making quantum processors into powerful new instruments of discovery.”

Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory is America’s national laboratory for particle physics and accelerator research. Fermi Forward Discovery Group manages Fermilab for the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science. Visit Fermilab’s website at www.fnal.gov and follow us on social media.

The Superconducting Quantum Materials and Systems Center at Fermilab is supported by the DOE Office of Science.

The Superconducting Quantum Materials and Systems Center is one of the five U.S. Department of Energy National Quantum Information Science Research Centers. Led by Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, SQMS is a collaboration of more than 40 partner institutions — national labs, academia and industry — working together to bring transformational advances in the field of quantum information science. The center leverages Fermilab’s expertise in building complex particle accelerators to engineer multiqubit quantum processor platforms based on state-of-the-art qubits and superconducting technologies. Working hand in hand with embedded industry partners, SQMS will build a quantum computer and new quantum sensors at Fermilab, which will open unprecedented computational opportunities. For more information, please visit www.sqmscenter.fnal.gov.

Installation crews with the U.S. Department of Energy’s Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory and CERN, the European Organization for Particle Physics, are working alongside the Sanford Underground Research Facility to begin building massive cryostats, giant insulated containers designed to hold liquid argon at an extremely cold temperature, for the leading-edge Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment.

The work is happening nearly a mile underground at SURF in Lead, South Dakota, where thousands of red steel beams were meticulously transported, one by one, from the surface down to the assembly area.

Once installed, the beams will form the outer structures of the experiment’s two detector module cryostats. Each will house approximately 17,000 tons of liquid argon maintained at approximately minus 300 degrees Fahrenheit.

Construction of detector module cryostats began in early November with crews from CERN, Fermilab and SURF. Credit:  Shawn Carmichael, Fermilab

“DUNE is Fermilab’s top priority,” said Norbert Holtkamp, director of Fermilab. “The entire organization is thrilled to see this work begin. Once underway, DUNE has the potential to help us broaden our fundamental understanding of our universe, as well as potentially open the door to new technological advances.”

Once operational, Fermilab will send a beam of neutrinos 800 miles (1,300 kilometers) through Earth to DUNE’s liquid-argon detectors in South Dakota. A second detector near the neutrino beam source at Fermilab will measure the particles before they begin their journey. Together, the facilities at Fermilab and the underground site in South Dakota form the Long-Baseline Neutrino Facility.

Neutrinos beam
Fermilab will send a beam of neutrinos approximately 800 miles (1,300 kilometers) through the Earth from Batavia, Illinois, to the liquid-argon-filled detectors in South Dakota. Credit: Fermilab

DUNE is an international collaboration of over 1,500 researchers hosted by Fermilab, including five DOE Office of Science laboratories. The more than 6,200 tons of steel being used on the cryostat modules are an in-kind contribution from CERN. CERN is leading the design, construction planning, logistics and installation of DUNE’s massive cryostats, working with a Minnesota-based structural steel contractor to assemble the structures deep underground in South Dakota.

“We have been lucky to see several milestones occur recently, such as the arrival of steel for both cryostats in Rapid City from Houston, to the celebration earlier this year marking the start of steel being lowered underground in Lead,” said Jolie Macier, project manager for the far detectors and cryogenics of DUNE. “This brings us one step closer to science.”

The DUNE experiment marks the first time CERN has made such significant contributions to an experiment happening outside of Europe.

“DUNE is Fermilab’s top priority. Once underway, DUNE has the potential to help us broaden our fundamental understanding of our universe, as well as potentially open the door to new technological advances.”

Norbert Holtkamp, director of Fermilab

“Collaboration is in CERN’s DNA, and our contribution to DUNE is a brilliant example of cross-organizational partnership,” said Mark Thomson, director general of CERN. “After years of planning and careful coordination, I am thrilled to see that we are ready to start installation.”

CERN is a leader in particle physics technologies, including the design of the unique cryostats for DUNE. Using its Neutrino Platform facility, CERN developed and built the ProtoDUNE detector, the first prototype of the two detector technologies that will be used in the DUNE far detector modules.

“The work that has been done is a full contribution of CERN’s expertise,” said Lluís Miralles, Neutrino Platform principal project engineer at CERN. “Not only did we contribute our technical know-how, but also the project management capabilities of the organization. CERN demonstrates here how, by design, we have in-house competencies to address requirements and challenges at all levels of the project.”

Each cryostat measures 216 feet long (65.8 meters), 62 feet wide (18.9 meters) and 60 feet high (18.3 meters). To illustrate the enormous size of the cryostats, each one is longer than a Boeing 747 airplane, and each one will stand a full story taller than the iconic Hollywood sign in Los Angeles.

A rendering of one of the cryostat modules that will house the liquid-argon detector. Credit: Fermilab

“SURF is proud to support this world-class research 4,850 feet (1,478 meters) below ground level. This massive experiment is slated to run into the late 2040s, with the potential to impact science for generations. In the process, it’s creating a home for some of the best and brightest scientific minds in the world and a range of high-paying jobs right here in the Black Hills,” said Mike Headley, SURF laboratory director and executive director of the South Dakota Science and Technology Authority.

A total of 2,600 red steel beams will be used to build DUNE’s two cryostat modules. SURF is responsible for shaft operations and logistics, ensuring that each of these steel beams — and other necessary installation equipment — is safely transported underground to the work site. In addition to the installation work underway in the South Cavern, SURF crews have begun lowering steel components for the second cryostat into the North Cavern, where assembly is expected to begin next year.

A portion of the 2,600 steel beams
A portion of the 2,600 steel beams destined for DUNE’s cryostats was transported nearly a mile underground and staged in the South Detector Cavern ahead of installation. Credit: Stephen Kenny, SURF

“This marks an incredible milestone for the collaboration and reflects the cross-continental partnerships between CERN, Fermilab and SURF that are essential to realizing this project,” said Sowjanya Gollapinni, co-spokesperson for DUNE. “This synergy is at the core of how big international collaborations work. We are thrilled to take this major step forward as we move closer to the transformative science that DUNE will deliver.”

The underground space of DUNE is planned to be completed by 2029, and the detector apparatus in 2030. From that date, a 1,800-strong worldwide team of researchers will begin probing the laws of nature more deeply than ever before, observing particles from the Sun and outer space. Using Fermilab’s PIP-II accelerator upgrade, the terrestrial neutrino beam is expected to be sent to the underground detectors in South Dakota by 2031, enabling DUNE’s long-term scientific program.

Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory is America’s national laboratory for particle physics and accelerator research. Fermi Forward Discovery Group manages Fermilab for the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science. Visit Fermilab’s website at www.fnal.gov and follow us on social media.